Drew Your Own Name in Secret Santa? What Each Fix Does to the Odds
The short version: the usual hat fixes are not equal. If people who draw their own name put it back and draw again, a group of 6 gets stuck at the last name 11.3% of the time, and the draws that do finish are not equally likely. Even a perfectly fair draw has a 40% chance that two people get each other, and about a two-in-three chance that someone draws the same person as last year. Here are the exact numbers for groups of 4 to 20, and the fix for each problem.
Our first Secret Santa odds post covered why about 63% of hat draws give someone their own name. This one covers what happens next.
The numbers by group size
| People | Valid draws (nobody gets themselves) | “Put it back” gets stuck | Two people draw each other | Someone repeats last year’s person |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 9 | 13.9% | 33.3% | 70.4% |
| 5 | 44 | 13.2% | 45.5% | 71.5% |
| 6 | 265 | 11.3% | 39.6% | 69.7% |
| 8 | 14,833 | 9.0% | 39.4% | 68.1% |
| 10 | 1,334,961 | 7.6% | 39.3% | 67.1% |
| 12 | 176,214,841 | 6.5% | 39.3% | 66.4% |
| 20 | 895,014,631,192,902,121 | 4.2% | 39.3% | 65.1% |
All figures are exact: they count every possible draw, nothing is sampled. “Last year” assumes last year’s draw was also fair.
Fix 1: “Put it back and draw again”
People draw in turn. If you pull your own name, you put it back and draw again. It sounds harmless, but it has two problems.
It can get stuck. If everyone else has drawn and the only slip left is the last person’s own name, there is nothing to do but start over. With 6 people that happens 11.3% of the time, about 1 draw in 9. Bigger groups get stuck less often, but even 20 people are stuck 4.2% of the time.
It is not fair, even when it finishes. Each possible finished draw should be equally likely. With “put it back”, they are not: early drawers choose from more slips than late drawers, so some arrangements come up far more often than others.
| People | Most likely draw vs least likely | Last person gets the first person | Fair chance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 3 times | 25.8% | 33.3% |
| 5 | 4 times | 19.2% | 25.0% |
| 6 | 5 times | 15.7% | 20.0% |
| 8 | 7 times | 11.5% | 14.3% |
In a group of 6, the most likely finished draw comes up 5 times as often as the least likely one, and the last person to draw gets the first person’s name 15.7% of the time instead of the fair 20%. Nobody will notice in one year, but it is not a fair draw.
Fix 2: reshuffle everything and start again
The fair fix is the dull one: if anyone draws their own name, everyone puts their slip back and the whole group draws again. Every valid draw is then equally likely (265 of them for 6 people). The cost is time: you need about 2.7 tries on average, because only about 37% of draws work first time.
This is what our Secret Santa generator does: it reshuffles the whole list until every rule holds, instead of patching a bad shuffle by swapping names, so it is fair and you never redraw by hand.
Two people who drew each other
A fair draw often contains a pair who simply swap gifts: A buys for B and B buys for A. In groups of 6 or more, that happens in about 4 valid draws in 10 (39.6% for 6 people). The figure barely moves as the group grows: it settles at 39.3%, which works out to 1 − e−1/2.
Some groups like it; others feel it spoils the surprise, because once you know you have someone, you can guess they might have you. If you want to rule it out, use the generator’s single circle option: everyone is linked in one loop (A gives to B, B to C, and so on back to A), so no two people can ever have each other.
The same person as last year
If your group did a fair draw last year and does another fair draw this year, the chance that at least one person ends up with the same giftee again is about 70% for 6 people and 66% for 12. It falls only slowly with group size. With a big group, a repeat is still more likely than not.
To stop it, add last year’s pairs as rules in the generator: turn off “Both ways” so each rule only blocks that one direction (Sam can’t get Alex again, but Alex can still get Sam). If the rules leave someone with no possible giftee, the generator says who is stuck instead of failing silently.
Which fix should you use?
| Method | Fair? | Can get stuck? | Stops pairs and repeats? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Put your own name back and redraw | No | Yes | No |
| Everyone redraws if anyone gets themselves | Yes | No (but about 2.7 tries) | No |
| Generator with rules (and single circle if you want) | Yes | No (it tells you if your rules make a draw impossible) | Yes |
How we calculated this
- Valid draws are derangements: arrangements where nobody gets their own name. We counted them with the standard recurrence and checked them against a full enumeration up to 8 people and against OEIS A000166. For 20 people there are 895,014,631,192,902,121 valid draws out of 2,432,902,008,176,640,000 possible ones, which match the rounded figures (more than 2.4 quintillion draws, about 895 quadrillion valid ones) Stephen Woodcock gives in The baffling statistics of Secret Santa (UTS, December 2023).
- Two people who drew each other: valid draws with no swapped pair are permutations whose cycles all have length 3 or more (OEIS A038205); the rest contain at least one pair.
- “Put it back”: exact probabilities over every possible state of the hat, plus the exact probability of every finished draw up to 8 people.
- Same as last year: exact for every group size, averaged over every possible fair draw last year. For each pattern of last year’s draw we counted this year’s draws that avoid both people’s own names and last year’s pairs (inclusion-exclusion over the forbidden pairs), and checked the result against a full listing of every pair of draws up to 7 people and 100,000-draw simulations up to 20.
- Every exact figure was also checked with 50,000 to 200,000 simulated draws (Python, seed 20261114). Calculated November 14, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What should you do if you draw your own name in Secret Santa?
The fair way is for everyone to put their slip back and draw again. Putting only your own name back and redrawing is quicker but slightly unfair, and the last person can be left with only their own name (11.3% of the time with 6 people).
How likely is it that two people get each other?
About 40% in any fair draw of 6 or more people. A single-circle draw makes it impossible.
How do I stop people getting the same person as last year?
Add last year’s pairs as one-way rules in a Secret Santa generator. Without rules, a repeat happens in about two draws out of three.